Detail of WPA poster, c. 1936. (Courtesy of the Library of Congress)
The WPA: Antidote to the Great Depression?
by Nick Taylor
When President Franklin D. Roosevelt took office in March
1933, estimates of the number of jobless workers in the
United States ranged from thirteen million to as high
as fifteen million – a quarter of the working population.
Every class of worker was affected: laborers, factory
workers, carpenters, plumbers, electricians, secretaries,
clerks, salesmen and women, teachers, architects, engineers.
No one was immune.
The new president spelled out the problem in his inaugural
address. “Our greatest primary task,” he
said, “is to put people to work.”
His first steps toward job creation, however, were
limited in scope, slow to gear up, or temporary. The
Civilian Conservation Corps paid young men to work in
national and state parks and forests; their numbers
never reached more than 300,000 at any given time, and
the $25 they sent home from their $30 monthly paychecks
had limited effect as stimulus. The Public Works Administration,
created under Title II of the National Industrial Recovery
Act, would build magnificent dams, bridges, and other
major projects that took a lot of planning. Its administrator,
interior secretary Harold Ickes, deliberated at length
before approving project plans, and these factors assured
that the PWA had a far greater impact on the national
infrastructure than on unemployment. The Civil Works
Administration put 4.3 million of the unemployed to
work during the winter of 1933-34 but closed, as designed,
after just five months; it prevented hardship during
a harsh winter but failed to deliver long-term benefits.
Roosevelt’s presidency was therefore two years
old before he launched his primary attack on unemployment
– the Works Progress Administration. Under administrator
Harry L. Hopkins, a former social worker who had headed
relief efforts in New York when Roosevelt was governor
and started the first federal relief agency once Roosevelt
was in the White House, the WPA put over three million
Americans to work in its first year of operation. Hopkins
believed fiercely in giving the poor the dignity of
work.
WPA rules were geared to maximize employment among
the people hardest hit by the depression. Ninety percent
of WPA jobs went to workers on relief, meaning that
they were certified as poor and in need of government
help. (Supervisors and administrators made up the remaining
ten percent.) Moreover, WPA rules specified that ninety
percent of project budgets would be spent on labor,
with the remainder to cover materials, machinery, and
administration. Both rules were designed to put money
in the hands of people who needed it the most, and therefore
would spend it most quickly, funneling money into the
economy.
There was plenty of work for the unemployed to do.
Even in the 1930s, the United States still had a largely
nineteenth century infrastructure. Rural and secondary
roads were for the most part unpaved, and rainy season
turned many of them into swamps of mud. The first thrust
of the WPA’s road-building program was improving
farm-to-market roads and also building new rural roads
and bridges where they were needed. The WPA also improved
and built new inter-city roads and paved countless city
streets and sidewalks. These helped not only farmers
but eased travel generally, benefitting sales and delivery
people, truckers, and commuters, indeed everyone whose
job depended on getting from one place to another safely,
quickly and efficiently.
Many homes outside of towns and cities had no running
water when the WPA came into being. Their residents
pumped water from wells and used outdoor privies that
attracted flies and were often sanitary hazards. WPA
workers built and installed hundreds of thousands of
sanitary “fly tight” privies that were designed
to keep the flies out.
More importantly in terms of public health, the WPA
built and improved water and sewer treatment systems
all around the country, from major cities including
Oakland, California, to small towns such as New Concord,
Ohio. The agency also drained swampy areas that bred
mosquitoes that caused malaria, installing free flowing
watercourses in their place.
The WPA also coincided with the start of civil aviation
in America. New, larger airplanes were just making inter-city
passenger service more efficient, but many of those
planes had no place to go. Travelers to New York City
had to land in Newark. Washington, D.C., used an airport
consolidated from two smaller fields split by a major
road, so that before planes landed and took off flagmen
had to go out and wave down traffic. The WPA used its
labor-intensive model to build and improve airports
from runways to hangars and administrative buildings.
It built LaGuardia Airport in New York, the city’s
first commercial airport, and National in Washington,
and hundreds more around the country.
WPA laborers and skilled trade workers also built thousands
of public buildings, from school and hospitals to city
halls and courthouses. Agency rules that limited spending
on materials often forced the builders to use native
stone and wood that gave much WPA construction a distinctive
look.
WPA construction projects were highly visible, both
because of the distinctive red, white, and blue signs
that went up on the sites and because work on roads
and streets assured there would be passersby. Groups
of men with shovels and wheelbarrows did much of the
work in these labor-intensive settings, and often one
group seemed to be waiting on the other. The WPA worker
leaning on his shovel became a cliché among critics
of Roosevelt’s New Deal, and comics and citizens
alike claimed the initials stood for “We Poke
Along” or “We Piddle Around.”
The WPA did more than just construction work. Its large
Women’s and Professional Projects division operated
thousands of sewing rooms where workers, the large majority
women, made clothing and bedclothes for families on
relief. Teachers taught adult education classes and
supplemented staff at local school districts whose numbers
were decimated by the economic crisis. Doctors and nurses
inoculated flood victims. Librarians and book repairers,
researchers, and newspaper indexers were among the other
white-collar workers for whom jobs were created by the
WPA.
Federal One, the WPA’s arts division, ran projects
in art, theater, music and writing. In addition to paintings,
prints and sculpture, the Federal Art Project created
murals in schools, hospitals, and other public buildings.
The Federal Theater Project staged everything from circuses
to puppet shows, and using non-relief talents like John
Houseman and Orson Welles, brought some of the most
memorable moments in American theater history to the
stage. The Federal Music Project was the largest of
the arts units, with about 15,000 workers and performers,
and it entertained millions who attended symphonic concerts,
operas, and popular music. The Federal Writers Project
nurtured great writers including Saul Bellow and Richard
Wright, and produced landmark guides to every state
and major city. Music and art classes also were enormously
popular, and reached millions of people.
The arts projects never employed more than 40,000,
a tiny portion of the workers employed by the WPA. The
rolls reached a total of about 3.3 million in the fall
of 1936. The success of WPA paychecks in stimulating
the economy might be judged by the unemployment rate,
which had dropped to fourteen percent early in 1937.
Roosevelt believed the economy had turned the corner
and moved to cut spending. WPA jobs were cut in half,
and its budget for the fiscal year starting July 1937
was $1.5 billion, less than a third of its original
appropriation of $4.8 billion. That fall employers and
employees started contributing to Social Security for
the first time, and Roosevelt also tightened bank reserve
requirements. The removal of stimulus was devastating,
a recession in which industrial production plunged along
with the stock market, and unemployment shot back up
to nineteen percent.
Roosevelt changed course in March of 1938, and by that
fall, WPA rolls reached their highest point at about
3.4 million.
The WPA’s remaining life was affected by the
calculus of war. Japan had invaded China in July 1937.
Hitler annexed Austria in March 1938 and took over the
Czechoslovakian border area called the Sudetenland that
fall. Italy under Mussolini was increasingly bellicose
after invading Ethiopia in 1935. Spanish fascists were
at war against the elected government. With the rise
of fascism in both hemispheres Roosevelt tried to prepare
the nation for a time when it might have to go to war.
America had neglected its military after World War
I. Isolationists held sway in Congress. They wanted
the country to stay out of any kind of foreign involvements.
In fact, the bill that created the WPA contained a provision
against certain types of military spending – “no
part of the appropriation shall be used for munitions,
warships, or military or naval materiel.” This
had not stopped military planners from using the WPA
to refurbish army and navy camps, however. In its first
months, the WPA approved tens of millions of dollars
for work on military posts around the country. It also
built hundreds of armories for National Guard units.
Once Hitler invaded Poland in 1939 and war spread throughout
Europe, defense spending started to ramp up. That included
more work on military bases by the WPA, but also production
of planes, warships and weapons that started to push
unemployment down. By the end of 1940 the unemployment
rate was back down to 14.6 percent.
Unemployment was still high enough to keep the WPA
in business, but its workers were increasingly employed
at military work – building barracks and other
buildings at bases that were rapidly expanding due to
the draft that started in the fall of 1940. The Lend-Lease
program by which the United States sent military aid
to England starting in 1941 reduced unemployment further
still.
In 1941, unemployment dropped below ten percent for
the first time since 1929. After Pearl Harbor that December,
all holds were off on military spending and WPA workers
moved quickly into the private economy. Unemployment
dropped to 5 percent in 1942, 1.9 percent in 1943 when
the WPA ended, and below one percent in 1944. It is
hard to argue with those who contend that it was the
war that ultimately ended the Depression.
But the legacy of the WPA points to its necessity.
It employed 8.5 million people in its eight years, and
there were always eligible people on the waiting list
for jobs. It brought America’s infrastructure
into the twentieth century, adding 650,000 miles of
roads and 78,000 bridges to the country’s transportation
network. It improved the nation’s health with
water and sewer treatment systems and new hospitals
that were among 125,000 new WPA-built civilian and military
buildings. It advanced the age of civil aviation with
800 new, improved or enlarged airports. Its work on
military bases and the workers it trained helped the
services meet the demands of World War II. It provided
comfort to millions in the form of clothing and bedding
they could not afford to buy, fed millions of children
hot school lunches they otherwise would have done without,
and brought the arts to millions who had never been
exposed to them. People today still play golf on WPA-built
courses, swim in WPA swimming pools, and ski at WPA
winter sports complexes. In all ways, the WPA broadened
Americans’ access to their country.
Nick Taylor is an independent scholar and the author
of American Made: The Enduring Legacy of the
WPA: When FDR Put the Nation to Work (Bantam,
2008).
|